Why I Don’t Take the Gains Tests Seriously

LETTER TO THE EDITOR

The Gains tests are a series of ACT-style assessments given in every class at WBHS. According to the district, these tests are used by teachers to adapt instruction to address gaps in student learning.

I don’t take the Gains Test seriously for a number of reasons. There are a multitude of standardized assessments that students are required to endure, semester after semester, on some occasions taking the same one for multiple classes. These tests, designed to measure academic growth of the student body, are not only irritating but a blatant waste of perfectly good time, filling class periods that could (and should) be spent doing anything of a more productive nature. One could argue that taking one or two days out of an entire semester to take a test for the good of the school does little or no harm, and that’s perfectly valid. The time spent isn’t excessive, and the tests are little more of a nuisance to most. What I’m most concerned with, however, is not the actual tests but what they stand for.

Our entire academic system is designed for assessment and measurement of students. Classes are taught so that when the time comes, students can be successful on the test. A prime example of this is any AP course, where the entire point of the work involved is to pass the final. This overbearing focus on the test has a horribly detrimental effect—it takes the joy out of learning. There is absolutely no concept of learning for the sake of learning. Procuring wisdom simply for one’s own enjoyment is an idea long extinct, replaced with a factory system pumping out standardized, creativity-deprived, test-taking robots. We are effectively training our students to believe that learning is an obligatory action only to be fulfilled at school, placing upon it a terribly negative connotation that has very little actual validity.

Perhaps this is unavoidable. I don’t claim to know much about the topic, though I am aware that completely doing away with tests is impossible and illogical. I would, however, call for the central focus of schooling to be taken away from assessment and placed on furthering knowledge for the good of oneself and the growth of mind and character. Make learning engaging and creative instead of mindless repetition and recitation, and I believe the effects would be enormous.

Tyson Diffor
East junior

The Current welcomes submissions from all students, faculty, administration, and community members, but reserves the right to edit for length or content.  Any column, editorial, or letter to the editor expresses the opinion of the author and not necessarily the entire staff.

2 Comments

Filed under School News and Features, Viewpoint

2 responses to “Why I Don’t Take the Gains Tests Seriously

  1. Jason Penterman

    The increasing intensity of U.S. K-12 public education testing and consequences tied to testing began in 1983 with the document: A Nation At Risk – U.S. Dept. of Education. Diane Ravitch, a former believer in this document’s premise, that U.S. public education was a disaster and getting worse, has done a complete 180 and dismantled arguments that public education is failing and that the increasing testing on the taxpayer’s dime and the students’ time are beneficial. U.S. public schools, as a nation, are now graduating the highest percentages of students of all colors, creeds and nationalities – ever. Student pregnancy rates and involvement in felony crime and violence has plummeted since records have been kept on such a thing. Licensed Teachers and administration are the best they have ever been trained. CIgarette use is down. Students are also tested more than ever to assist teacher pay for performance compensation plans, school district pay for performance (low test scores = budget cuts) and facilitate privatizing “failing” schools. My wonderful private and public education through the 70s through 80s was much different. I inform people of my concerns. Thank You for writing this Tyson.

    http://dianeravitch.net/?s=a+nation+at+risk

  2. Susan Kornemann Hansen

    Excellent points Tyson. Check out Campbell’s Law regarding high stakes testing and it’s corruption . http://dianeravitch.net/2012/05/25/what-is-campbells-law/

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s