The Most Repetitive Time of the Year


TV Talk Logo

Exactly what it says on the tin.

We’ve all seen them, the obligatory Christmas special that every TV show gets around this time of year. They’re often poorly thought out, rushed, and they always have the main character or the villain learning the (gag) “True spirit of Christmas.”

It’s lame, uninspired and a box to check on a script writer’s agenda list.

But you’re probably not wondering, “I’m a person that aspires to go into television writing (and a talentless hack), so I want to know how to produce Christmas specials.” So I present to you a complete template of how to make a cookie cutter Christmas special.

First things first on our dull little Christmas adventure: cover everything in snow! Want to express that it’s the holiday season in whatever setting the story is taking place? SNOW! Just spread some snow and ice everywhere, have at least one shot of it snowing outside and bam… instant Christmas!

Next on the list, choose your poison (story poison). You can either take the “doesn’t know the meaning of Christmas” route, the “can’t find the perfect gift” route, or the “save Santa” route or just retell A Christmas Carol like everybody before you. If your answer is one of the former, read on. If the latter, just accept that it will never be able to retell the classic better than Scrooge McDuck did, and be on yer merry way.

Now that you’ve chosen your cookie cutter problem, just shoehorn it into the story somehow.

The protagonist doesn’t know the true meaning of Christmas? Just have them go on a Christmas adventure until they realize what “the true spirit of Christmas” is. Villain doesn’t have the Christmas spirit? Have the main character give a good, long (preachy) speech about how “Christmas is about sharing n’ stuff.”

Protagonist having trouble finding the perfect gift? Just sell one of your prized possessions to purchase a very expensive object that the main character knows the person they are buying it for will love, only for them to find out that the person whom the gift was for has done the same thing as the protagonist—thus rendering both gifts useless!


“A Very Supernatural Christmas”

Need to save Santa? (Do I even have to elaborate with this one?)

So, Santa is saved, gifts are given and the value of a stock phase is truly comprehended. How can you possibly end this? Three words: Obnoxious. Holiday. Song. Something that even the most shameless purveyor of overpriced clothing would call “a lyrical abomination that no sane person could conceive” is preferable. Bonus points if the actors sound bored or in pain while singing them.

So there. A perfect mold for your limp and over-told story. But wait a minute. Are there any good examples of Christmas specials? Well…

  • The Peanuts: Merry Christmas Charlie Brown: Yes, the animation has aged badly, yes, the voice acting quality is laughable, but it’s a TV classic nonetheless. It’s also the grandfather of the Christmas pageant special (and a good example of how to do it right, too).
  • House: The Christmas Episodes: These are actually really bizarre examples of good Christmas specials, because of how it’s incredibly poor in execution. Surprisingly enough, this is what makes the special good. The writers made such a thin attempt at working in the Christmas elements that it just ends up being an episode of House with a thin Christmas film over it. Don’t misunderstand, this special still has every trope in the book, but each is so poorly executed that it never really bleeds into the episodes at all.
  • A Very Supernatural Christmas: This is probably the best one on here. Not only does it not shove the Christmas spirit into your eye sockets, but it actually uses the Christmas theme to make a pretty great episode. Without spoiling too much, they fight multiple Krampus-like monsters (Krampi) and use ancient paganistic rituals to justify the means. When is the last time you heard of a Christmas special event mention anything outside of Santa or Scrooge, much less address paganism or Krampus. (What do you mean, Krampus 2015? That movie never happened…)

Wow, Christmas episodes that either used Christmas to add to the story through good writing or just didn’t care and were good regardless. Wondrous, isn’t it? It’s almost like putting effort into a Christmas script can yield a plethora of unique ideas and make your show better and more respectable if you pull it off.

Perhaps that idea is “The True Potential of the Christmas Special.” (Wink.)

(Parody “House” image by Robert Pulford, Current Staff. Image from “Supernatural” is official publicity material from the CW.)

TV Talk is a regular television column written by Robert Pulford, Current Staff.

Leave a comment

Filed under Entertainment, Viewpoint

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s